Ranch, Blue Cheese, Oil & Vinegar, Honey Mustard, Out Island Sauce, **Orange Walnut Vinaigrette and **Italian

Add to any salad:

Fried, grilled or blackened | Tuna $12.95
Chicken $7.95 | Mahi $11.95 | Lobster $13.95
Shrimp $9.95 | Snapper $14.95 | Grouper $14.95

**House Salad

Mixed greens, cucumbers, carrots, tomatoes and onions. $8.95

Wedge Salad

Quartered iceberg lettuce topped with bleu cheese crumbles, chopped bacon and diced onion. Served with bleu cheese dressing. $10.95


Chopped romaine with parmesan cheese, garlic croutons and traditional caesar dressing. $9.95

Cobb Salad

A bed of mixed greens with chopped bacon, tomato, hardboiled egg and bleu cheese crumble. Served with Italian dressing. $13.95

**Key’s Conch Chowder

Homemade the way it’s supposed to be. $8.00 bowl

Stone Crab Chowder

A true taste of the Keys. $8.00 bowl

*Tuna Nachos

Diced raw ahi tuna and seaweed salad served on wonton chips, drizzled with a sweet soy sauce reduction, wasabi cream and sriracha sauces. $16.95

Fried “Or” Coconut Shrimp (4)

Hand battered, lightly fried and served with orange horseradish sauce. $12.50 Add coconut $.50

Sunset Conch Fritters (6)

Ground conch meat lightly fried in a homemade seasoned batter and served with Out Island Sauce. $11.95

**Peppercorn Crusted Tuna

Sliced and lightly seared, drizzled with a sweet soy sauce reduction, wasabi cream and sriracha sauces. Served over seaweed salad $16.95

**Bacon Wrapped Shrimp (5)

Extra large shrimp wrapped in bacon, fried and drizzled with a sweet Thai chili sauce. $14.95

Lorelei’s Smoked Fish Dip

Smoked local fish with island spices, topped with capers & diced onions. Served with crackers. $13.95

Sante Fe Chicken Egg Rolls

Adobo seasoned chicken with corn, black beans, roasted red peppers served with lime cilantro aioli. $11.95


Freshly fried tortilla chips covered in our house crafted cheese sauce then topped with pico de gallo, sour cream and guacamole. $12.95 Add Beef $4.00 | Chicken $2.00 | Pork $3.00

**Peel & Eat Shrimp

Steamed and served chilled or warm, with or without island spices. 1/2lb $15.25 | 1lb $26.50

Fried Chicken Wings (10)

Available in Mild, Medium, Hot, Sweet Chili, BBQ or Teriyaki. Served with celery and choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing. $12.95

Poppy’s Pretzels

Bavarian-style pretzel logs served with warm “beer cheese” and spicy mustard dipping sauces. $10.95

Captain’s Quesadilla

Grilled flour tortilla stuffed with a blend of cheeses. Served with sour cream, guacamole and salsa on the side. $11.95
Vegetables $12.95/Double vegetables $13.50
Grilled Chicken $14.25/Double Chicken $16.75
Shaved Steak $15.50/Double Steak $18.50
Grilled Shrimp $17.50/Double Shrimp $22.00
Lobster $25.00/Double Lobster $34.00

Buffalo Chicken Dip

Shredded chicken with buffalo sauce, butter and cream cheese served with tortilla chips for dipping. Bleu cheese or ranch dressing on the side. $12.95

Fried Mozzarella

House battered & fried mozzarella triangles served with marinara sauce. $9.95

Cabana Madness

Giant platter of buffalo wings, conch fritters, peel & eat shrimp, snow crab and smoked fish dip. $48.50

Served with a pickle spear and your choice of house-made chips, fries or fisherman’s slaw.
Sub sweet potato fries or onion rings for an additional $2.00.
Add Bacon $2.00 | Add Mushrooms $2.50 | Add Cheese $1.50
(American, Swiss, Provolone, Cheddar or Pepper Jack)

Lorelei’s World Famous Fish Sandwich

Grilled, fried or blackened, with lettuce, tomato & onion on a Brioche bun
Mahi $16.95 | Snapper $20.95 | Grouper $20.95

Brisket Burnt Ends Sausage Sandwich

Smoked brisket burnt ends are used to make this artisan sausage served on a toasted French baguette topped with spicy brown mustard and Guinness braised onions. $14.95

*Hand Formed Cabana Burger

8oz. certified Angus burger with lettuce, tomato & onion on a Brioche bun. $12.95

Smoked Turkey Sandwich

House smoked turkey breast on grilled Texas toast with bacon, LTO & cranberry mayo. $16.95

BLT Sandwich

Double cut bacon, marinated beefsteak tomato, caper mayo and mixed greens on Texas toast. $14.95

Philly Cheesesteak

Shaved sirloin steak grilled on the flattop, loaded with peppers, onions, mushrooms on a toasted French baguette with your choice of cheese. $14.95

Caprese Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken breast with locally sourced basil pesto, marinated beefsteak tomato & fresh mozzarella finished with a balsamic glaze & served on a Ciabatta roll $16.95

*Pulled Pork Sliders (3)

House smoked & topped with a crispy onion ring, creamy coleslaw & pickles on mini Brioche buns. Sweet BBQ or vinegar based Carolina BBQ sauce from Copperline Original BBQ available. $14.95

Chicken Fried Steak Sandwich

Steak pounded thin and flash fried topped with an Asian slaw & Yum-Yum sauce on a Ciabatta roll $16.95

Loredei Entrees

Most entrees served with your choice of caribbean coconut rice and beans and sautéed vegetables OR double french fries

Catch of the Day

Choice of grilled, fried, or blackened.
Mahi $28.95 | Snapper $32.95 | Grouper $32.95

Key Lime Peppercorn Snapper

Fresh Snapper in a key lime peppercorn sauce. $32.95
Mahi $28.95 | Grouper $32.95 | Chicken $20.95

Fried “or” Coconut Shrimp (8)

Hand battered, lightly fried and served with orange horseradish sauce. $22.25 | Add Coconut $.50

Mac & Cheese

No sides included. Plain $13.95 | Bacon & Jalapeño $14.95
Pulled Pork $18.95 | Lobster $25.00

*12oz New York Strip Steak

Char-grilled to your taste. $32.50

**Alaskan Snow Crab Platter

A full pound of Alaskan Snow Crab clusters served with drawn butter, fries and fisherman’s slaw. $32.95

Filet Mignon Sliders

Twin filet mignon medallions on mini brioche buns topped with caramelized onions & provolone cheese. Sides not included. $23.95

Own Catch Dinner

Fish must be brought to the restaurant filleted. Option of grilled, fried or blackened served with french fries and fisherman’s slaw.
$12.95 per person/per pound

Seafood Tacos

Three soft tacos grilled, fried or blackened with cabbage, tomatoes, mixed cheeses & a cilantro lime mayo. No sides included
Mahi $18.95 | Shrimp $19.95
Grouper $21.95 | Snapper $21.95

**Vegan Sautee

Fried cauliflower rice, garlic, tomatoes, onions,mushrooms & the vegetable of the day. Pan sautéed in ginger as well as white & green onion. $16.95 | With cheese $17.95

Twin Lobster Tails

Two cold water char-grilled lobster tails. $35.95

Surf & Turf

12 oz NY strip steak char-grilled to your liking & paired with a grilled cold water lobster tail. $43.95

Little Mates & Mermaids

12 years old and under. Served with a choice of fries or vegetables.

All Selections Are $7.95

Chicken Nuggets | Fish Fingers | Mini Cheeseburger
Grilled Cheese | Hot Dog

Lorelei’s World Famous “Frozen”
Key Lime Pie

Whipped and creamy but less tart than standard key lime pie. Topped with mango sauce and whipped cream. $6.95

Frozen Orange Creamsicle Pie

Sorry kids, this one is for the adults only! Whipped and creamy like our key lime pie with the addition of vanilla, orange juice, lots of dark rum and fresh orange zest. $6.95

Traditional Key Lime Pie

Custard based with whipped cream. $6.95

Bistro Chocolate Fudge Cake

Whipped cream and chocolate sauce. $6.95

Caribbean Rice $2.50
Black Beans $2.50
Fisherman’s Slaw (Vinegar based) $2.50
Pasta Salad $2.50
Creamy Coleslaw $2.50
French Fries $3.00
Chips $3.00
Sweet Potato Fries $3.50
Onion Rings $4.00
Vegetables of The Day $2.50
Mac & Cheese $7.95