Dressings:
Ranch, Blue Cheese, Oil & Vinegar, Honey Mustard, Out Island Sauce, **Orange Walnut Vinaigrette and **Italian
Add to any salad:
Fried, grilled or blackened
Chicken $7.95 | Shrimp $9.95
Mahi $11.95 | Lobster $13.95
Snapper $12.95 | Grouper $12.95
**Side House
Mixed greens, cucumbers, carrots, tomatoes and onions. $8.95
**Spinach
Fresh spinach with tomatoes, red onions, bacon bits, walnuts, blue cheese crumbles and mushrooms. Served with our orange walnut vinaigrette. $11.95
Caesar
Chopped romaine with parmesan cheese, garlic croutons and a traditional caesar dressing. $9.95
Cobb Salad
A bed of mixed greens with chopped bacon, tomato, avocado, hardboiled egg and bleu cheese crumble. Served with Italian dressing. $13.95
**Key’s Conch Chowder
Homemade the way it’s supposed to be.
$8.00 bowl
Stone Crab Chowder 
A true taste of the Keys. $8.00 bowl
Lobster Bisque
$9.00 bowl
*Tuna Nachos
Diced raw ahi tuna and seaweed salad served on wonton chips, drizzled with a sweet soy sauce reduction, wasabi cream and sriracha sauces. $16.95
Fried “Or” Coconut
Shrimp (4)
Hand battered, lightly fried and served with orange horseradish sauce. $12.50
Add coconut $.50
Sunset Conch Fritters (6)
Ground conch meat lightly fried in a homemade seasoned batter and served with Out Island Sauce. $10.95
**Peppercorn Crusted Tuna
Sliced and lightly seared, drizzled with a sweet soy sauce reduction, wasabi cream and sriracha sauces. Served over seaweed salad. $15.95
**Bacon Wrapped
Shrimp (5)
Extra large shrimp wrapped in bacon, fried and drizzled with a sweet Thai chili sauce. $14.95
Lorelei’s Smoked Fish Dip
Smoked local fish with island spices, topped with capers & diced onions. Served with crackers. $13.95
Steak on Truffle Bread
Sliced NY Strip steak on truffle parmesan focaccia with a cream horseradish sauce. $17.95
Sante Fe Chicken Egg Rolls
Adobo seasoned chicken with corn, black beans, roasted red peppers served with lime cilantro aioli. $11.95
**Peel & Eat Shrimp
Steamed and served chilled or warm, with or without island spices. 1/2lb $15.25 | 1lb $26.50
Fried Chicken Wings (10)
Available in Mild, Medium, Hot, Sweet Chili, BBQ or Teriyaki. Served with celery and choice of ranch or bleu cheese dressing. $12.95
Poppy’s Pretzels
Bavarian-style pretzel logs served with warm “beer cheese” and spicy mustard dipping sauces. $10.95
Captain’s Quesadilla
Grilled flour tortilla stuffed with a blend of cheeses. Served with sour cream, guacamole and salsa on the side. $11.95
Vegetables $12.95
Grilled Chicken $14.25
Shaved Steak $15.50
Grilled Shrimp $17.50
Lobster $25.00
Cabana Madness
Giant platter of buffalo wings, conch fritters, peel & eat shrimp, snow crab and smoked fish dip. $44.50
Served with a pickle spear and your choice of house-made chips, fries or fisherman’s slaw.
Sub sweet potato fries or onion rings for an additional $2.00.
Add Bacon $2.00 | Add Mushrooms $2.50 | Add Cheese $1.50
(American, Swiss, Provolone, Cheddar or Pepper Jack)
Lorelei’s World Famous
Fish Sandwich
Grilled, fried or blackened, with lettuce, tomato and onion on a Kaiser roll.
Mahi $16.95 | Snapper $18.95 | Grouper $18.95
Impossible Burger
Vegan plant based burger patty topped with caramelized onions, roasted red peppers and Out Island Sauce on a Kaiser roll. $16.95
*Hand Formed Cabana Burger
8oz. certified Angus burger with lettuce, tomato and onion on a pretzel roll. $12.95
Smoked Turkey Sandwich
House smoked turkey breast on grilled Texas toast with bacon, LTO and cranberry mayo. $14.95
French Dip
Shaved prime rib on a toasted French baguette with swiss cheese, caramelized onions and au jus. Served with parmesan cheese fries. $17.95
Tex Mex Sandwich
Grilled or blackened chicken topped with guacamole, pico de gallo, lettuce, tomato, onion, and a lime chipotle aioli on a Kaiser roll. $13.95
*Pulled Pork Kaiser Sliders (3)
Smoked on premise and topped with a crispy onion ring, creamy coleslaw, bread and butter pickles on mini Brioche buns. Sweet BBQ or vinegar based Carolina BBQ sauce available. $14.95
Most entrees served with your choice of caribbean coconut rice and beans and sautéed vegetables OR double french fries
Catch of the Day
Choice of grilled, fried, or blackened.
Mahi $26.50 | Snapper $27.50 | Grouper $27.50
Key Lime Peppercorn Snapper
Fresh Snapper in a key lime peppercorn sauce. $27.50
Mahi $26.50 | Grouper $27.50 | Chicken $18.25
Fried “or” Coconut Shrimp (8)
Hand battered, lightly fried and served with orange horseradish sauce. $22.25 | Add Coconut $.50
Mac & Cheese
Served with toasted breadcrumbs. No sides included.
Plain $13.95 | Bacon & Jalapeño $14.95 | Pulled Pork $18.95 | Lobster $25.00
*12oz New York Strip Steak
Char-grilled to your taste. $30.50
**Alaskan Snow Crab Platter
A full pound of Alaskan Snow Crab clusters served with drawn butter, fries and fisherman’s slaw. $29.50
Surf & Turf
12 oz NY strip steak char-grilled to your liking and paired with a grilled cold water lobster tail. $41.95
Own Catch Dinner
Fish must be brought to the restaurant filleted. Option of grilled, fried or blackened served with french fries and fisherman’s slaw.
$12.95 per person/per pound
Seafood Tacos
Three soft tacos grilled, fried or blackened with cabbage, tomatoes, mixed cheeses and a cilantro lime mayo. No sides included.
Mahi $16.95 | Shrimp $18.25
Grouper $19.25 | Snapper $19.25
**Vegan Sautee
Red skinned potatoes with vegetable of the day, garlic, tomatoes, mushrooms, basil and onions. $11.95 | With cheese $12.95
Add Impossible Burger $7.50
Filet Mignon Sliders
Twin Filet Mignon medallions on mini brioche buns topped with caramelized onions and provolone cheese. Served with fries. $21.95
Twin Lobster Tails
Two cold water char-grilled lobster tails. $31.95
Little Mates & Mermaids
12 years old and under. Served with a choice of fries or vegetables.
All Selections Are $7.95
Chicken Nuggets | Fish Fingers | Mini Cheeseburger
Grilled Cheese | Hot Dog
Caribbean Rice $2.50
Black Beans $2.50
Fisherman’s Slaw (Vinegar based) $2.50
Pasta Salad $2.50
Creamy Coleslaw $2.50
French Fries $3.00
Chips $3.00
Sweet Potato Fries $3.50
Onion Rings $4.00
Vegetables of The Day $2.50
Mac & Cheese $7.95
Lorelei’s World Famous “Frozen”
Key Lime Pie
Whipped and creamy but less tart than standard key lime pie. Topped with mango sauce and whipped cream. $6.95
Traditional Key Lime Pie
Custard based with whipped cream. $6.95
Bistro Chocolate Fudge Cake
Whipped cream and chocolate sauce. $6.95
